Why Elon Musk Is Dead Wrong About Retirement Savings
β
Itβs October 1929.
β
Irving Fisher, Yale economist, millionaire investor, one of the most respected financial minds in America, stands in front of a room and says something that will haunt him forever:
β
"Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau."
β
He's dead certain. The market is solid. The future is secure. People should keep investing.
β
Three weeks later, the stock market implodes. Thousands of investors are wiped out. Fisher loses everything, the modern equivalent of hundreds of millions of dollars.
β
Gone.
β
Here's a guy with all the credentials, all the wealth, all the expertise, and he's catastrophically, historically wrong about what's coming next.
β
Fast forward to today.
β
Elon Musk, worth over $200 billion, just told people they shouldn't worry about saving for retirement. His reasoning? In 10 or 20 years, AI and robots will create so much abundance that money "won't matter."
β
Sound familiar?
β
Because history has a pretty clear message: being a billionaire doesn't make you a prophet. And betting your financial future on a tech utopia that may or may not happen is a really good way to end up broke.
β
Today, we're breaking down what Elon actually said, why his vision is disconnected from the reality most people are living in right now, and why you absolutely should still be saving for retirement, regardless of what billionaires say about robot futures.
β
Let's get into it.
β
What Elon Actually Said
β
Let's start with what Elon Musk actually said in a recent podcast.
β
He told people they shouldn't "worry about squirreling money away for retirement in 10 or 20 years" because it "won't matter."
β
His claim is that advanced AI and robotics will create extreme abundance.
β
Goods and services will become so cheap, essentially non-scarce, that traditional money stops being as important.
β
In Elon's vision, AI and robots supercharge productivity and drive the cost of almost everything toward zero. You won't need to work for basic needs.
β
Healthcare and education will be dramatically better and virtually free.
β
He pairs this with the idea of "universal high income," not just universal basic income, but a bigger version, where governments redistribute corporate and AI profits so everyone gets a large guaranteed income.
β
In that world, he argues, retirement savings would be "irrelevant" because you could just have whatever you want without needing a big nest egg.
β
It's a compelling vision. It's also speculation masquerading as financial advice.
β
Why This Is Dangerously Disconnected From Reality
β
Let's talk about why this is a problem.
β
#1 We're Not Living in That World Today
β
Right now, Americans are dealing with high cumulative inflation, elevated interest rates, and an affordability crisis in housing, healthcare, and education.
β
That's the opposite of "money doesn't matter."
β
Housing costs have exploded. Healthcare is bankrupting families. College tuition keeps climbing. Rent is eating half of people's paychecks.
β
Surveys show that most people are behind on retirement savings today and are already anxious about not having enough, even under the old rules, before we even start talking about AI.
β
So telling people not to worry about saving for retirement because robots will make everything free isn't just premature. It's reckless.
β
#2 This Is Speculation, Not Financial Planning
β
Elon's take is a long-term tech speculation narrative. It's a vision of a possible future that may or may not happen.
β
But you cannot, and should not, make personal finance decisions today based on speculative technology outcomes 10 or 20 years from now.
β
What if AI doesn't deliver this utopia? What if it takes 30 years instead of 10?
β
What if the transition is messy, uneven, and filled with economic disruption?
β
What if the benefits of AI and robotics accrue mostly to people who already own capital, like billionaires, and don't get redistributed the way Elon is imagining?
β
If you stop saving for retirement today based on Elon's prediction, and that prediction doesn't come true, you're screwed. You've lost years of compounding. You've lost the most valuable asset you have: time.
β
#3 Even in an AI-Abundant Future, Money Will Still Matter
β
Let's play devil's advocate for a second. Let's say Elon is right. Let's say AI and robots create massive abundance.
β
Even in that world, money will still matter for relative scarcity.
β
Sure, maybe robots can make food and basic goods cheap. But what about things that are inherently scarce? Prime real estate. Rare experiences.
β
Status goods. Access to the best schools, the best doctors, the best neighborhoods.
β
Throughout all of human history, even as we've gotten wealthier and more abundant, there have always been things people compete for. And money has always been the medium of that competition.
β
The idea that we're going to reach a post-scarcity utopia where nobody needs money isn't just optimistic. It's historically naive.
β
Why You Should Ignore This Advice
β
Here's the bottom line: Elon Musk is worth over $200 billion. He doesn't need to save for retirement. He could lose 99% of his wealth and still be a billionaire.
β
So when he says, "Don't worry about saving for retirement," he's speaking from a position of total financial security that 99.99% of people will never have.
β
For everyone else, meaning you, here's what you should do instead.
β
1. Keep Saving for Retirement
β
Max out your 401(k). Max out your Roth IRA. Invest in low-cost index funds.
β
Let compounding work over decades.
β
The math on retirement savings is simple: the earlier you start, the more time your money has to grow. If you wait 10 or 20 years because you believed Elon's AI utopia was coming, you've lost the most powerful force in investing: time.
β
If the AI utopia does arrive and you end up with more money than you need?
β
Great. That's a good problem to have. You can spend it, give it away, or leave it to your kids.
β
But if the AI utopia doesn't arrive, or arrives slower, or messier, or less evenly than predicted, and you didn't save? You're in a really bad spot.
β
2. Plan for the World You're Living In, Not the World Elon Is Imagining
β
Right now, the world requires money to live. You need money for housing, food, healthcare, transportation, childcare, and everything else.
β
That reality isn't changing anytime soon. So plan accordingly.
β
Build an emergency fund. Pay off high-interest debt. Invest consistently in diversified, low-cost funds. Increase your income over time. Live below your means.
β
Those principles have worked for decades. They'll continue to work, regardless of what happens with AI.
β
3. Don't Let Billionaires Distract You from Fundamentals
β
Billionaires love to talk about grand visions and futuristic possibilities. That's fine. It's fun to think about.
β
But don't confuse that with actionable financial advice.
β
The fundamentals of personal finance don't change because Elon Musk says robots are coming. Spend less than you earn. Save consistently. Invest for the long term. Minimize fees and taxes. Let compounding do the work.
β
That's how regular people build wealth. Not by betting on speculative futures, but by executing boring, proven strategies over decades.
β
The Bigger Picture
β
Look, I'm not anti-AI. I'm not anti-technology. I think AI will change the world in profound ways. It already is.
β
But I'm also a realist. And the reality is that technological change is messy, uneven, and often takes way longer than people predict.
β
Self-driving cars were supposed to be everywhere by 2020. They're still not.
β
Flying cars have been "just around the corner" for 70 years. Still waiting.
β
Nuclear fusion has been "20 years away" for the last 60 years.
β
The point is: don't bet your financial future on technology predictions from people who have no skin in the game if they're wrong.
β
Elon Musk will be fine whether AI creates a utopia or not. Will you?
β